Point/Counterpoint Prop 206

Point/Counterpoint Prop 206

December 19, 2016

In this past election season, Arizona recently passed Prop 206 to raise the minimum wage. In 2017, the minimum wage will raise to $10 and ultimately in 2020 the wage will be $12 an hour. This controversial prop has sparked several debates mentioning the positive and negative aspects of its passing.

More money, more problem$

Caden Johnson

I’m about to start making so much more money, I’m going to buy so much stuff. I think I might buy a house boat.

Prop 206 plans to raise Arizona’s minimum wage from the current $8.05 to $12 per hour over the course of several years. It sounds awesome. People that work minimum wage jobs will earn more money for the same amount of work, so they will be able to better support their families, right?

Wrong.

It is easy to assume that this prop will be a good thing, but we need to look deeper into this.

Let’s look at the effect this will have on businesses. Because the minimum wage has risen, the business owners are going to have to pay their employees more. Did the wages rise for the bosses? No. Therefore, the bosses are going to have to come up with extra money to pay their employees with.

So what are they going to do? I can tell you now that most business executives are not going to take much money out of their own salary. They are going to cut working hours and/or jack up the prices of their products.

But no big deal right? Everything has just raised in cost to shift to the new minimum wage standard so it is the same! Wrong again. Here are two reasons why: some people will not be able to afford what they once could and all the money that people have saved up over the years will decrease in value.

Because your wage has risen by about 50 percent, congratulations! You have have been moved to a higher income tax bracket! Now, instead of paying the original percent of your income, you are paying an even higher percent of your money. Suddenly, you do not have the equivalent amount of savings as before.

And don’t think the tax brackets will change accordingly either; this is on the federal scale, so they are not going to change the whole system just because Arizona changed.

What about the middle and upper class people that are doing just fine and have saved up money over the years? They get hurt too. All that saved money will remain the same, even though inflation has blown up all around it. In turn, the money that was once worth so much is now worth considerably less.

Not one part of the system will be benefitted. The lower class loses their precious working hours, the middle class loses value in their savings, the upper class loses money having to pay their employees more, and everyone pays a higher percentage of taxes to the government.

There is only one winner here: the federal government.

Leave a Comment

More money, less problem$

With the passing of prop 206 in Arizona this past election season resulting in raising the minimum wage from $8.05 to $10 in 2017 to ultimately $12 in 2020 brings a sense of hope to many Arizonans with the aspect of a better life. However, this accomplishment has led to some backlash with those preaching, “Inflation, inflation!”

Those opponents yelling about inflation fail to realize that if the real minimum wage in 1968 at $1.60 was adjusted for inflation today it would be $10.86, not $8.05. This results in large businesses and corporations getting away with paying their employees much less than they once were.

The measly minimum wage of $8.05 does not currently coincide with the price of living. Around 790,000 workers would benefit from this increase and according to the Economic Policy Institute, 90 percent of workers who would benefit are at least 20 years old. This means that teenagers are not the primarily minimum wage worker.

There are constantly arguments that low-wage workers should not receive more compensation for an entry level job should tell that to Maria Fernandes, a 32 year old woman died in 2014, Fernandes worked four jobs to try to make ends meet. She died while taking a nap in between shifts from the fumes in her car.

America is known as the land of opportunity and that if one works hard each and everyday they can succeed. The low wage wage of $8.05 cuts the idea of social mobility and opportunity.

Another popular argument maintains that the passing of prop 206 will result in both small and large businesses to crumble and result in bankruptcy. However, an increase of minimum wage will not bankrupt businesses.

PBS reported that in most cases an hourly wage of a worker creates a small dent in the profit of a corporation. While more research constructed by the New York Times shows that overtime businesses will adjust to the wage increases and potentially have an increase in profits from a greater productivity of their employees.

Along with the minimum wage raising, employees will now have the right to earn paid sick leave from their employers; every 30 hours worked will in turn equal one hour of paid sick leave.These paid sick days will allow employees to be able to take off work instead of being overworked or going into work sick because of the fear of being fired.

The proposition takes the burden off of families struggling to make ends meet and substantially decrease poverty in Arizona. It would also ensure that more families can meet their basic needs and allow them to live better, healthier lives. Ultimately, the passing Of prop 206 is creating a better quality of life.

Leave a Comment

The Precedent • Copyright 2024 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in